|
Dr
Richard Wiseman seems to be unable to do anything right, you may be asking yourself. He messed up almost every experiment
he has done you may think. Well, it certainly looks like he is not a very good paranormal investigator. He has a group of
so called scientists in his army of sceptics. Ray Hyman has as recently as tonight, 7 Nov 2004 been on a TV show on Ch4 in
UK. It said he was working for the CIA….. Why would the CIA want to employ friends and fellow associates of Dr Wiseman.
I am just a humble psychic, I cannot answer this. I am the kind of person who the sceptics despise and put down
at every opportunity. Yet, I can find fault with the way this Professor at the University of Hertfordshire in England has
conducted most of his scientific work. How can an uneducated fool like me do this? I found the most obvious faults with his
fire walking study…….. and what he tried to do to the poor Russian girl Natasha, well you can read about that
all over the internet.
This was published in the Society of Psychical Research Journal in October 2004
Wiseman Correspondence Fire walking SPR vol 67 No 873
In this article Wiseman concludes that in fire walking
when injury is not sustained by firewalkers, nothing paranormal has occurred. He puts it like this..
“The
results of this experiment combined with those obtained by Price in 1937, demonstrate that, in the case of fire walking at
least, neither divine intervention nor self belief can overcome the principle of physics.”
So let us examine
what Wiseman did to arrive at this conclusion. Wiseman quotes
“ In 1937 Harry Price arranged for an Indian
firewalker and fakir named Ahmen Hussain to visit Britain for testing. Price first ask Hussain to walk barefoot over a bed
of embers 12 feet long and with a surface temperature of 575 degrees Centigrade. Hussain completed the walk unharmed.”
Now, Price then speculated according to Wiseman, that the heat transferred to the feet during this walk was not
enough to cause burning. Price then increased the temperature to 740 degrees Centigrade and extended the walk to 20 feet. Now, we are told that in this new trial the fakir suffered burns to his feet. What we are not told is, if Price
asked people not claiming this power to walk on fire for 12 feet at 575 degrees to see if they could do it without being burned.
The real test would be to see if this could be performed by anyone. If anyone could do it as Price seems to suggest, why are
we not told this, as it seems to me the reasonable test would be to compare like with like. I am sure even if a paranormal
phenomena does exist, there would always be a point where it stopped working and burning would result. I am sure that the
phenomena if it does exist would have boundaries within which it occurred. Most thing in science work within boundaries.
So how then did Wiseman replicate this? I am sure he wanted to be able to say that nothing paranormal was going on.
Well, Wiseman increased the temperature from 575 degrees and increased the distance from 12 feet, remember the experiment
had a positive result for Price and his fakir at these levels. Wiseman increased the distance to 60 feet and the temperature
to 700 degrees, I am sure in the hope that his subjects would be burned and he could show the world and BBC TV who were filming
this experiment that fire walking had nothing paranormal going on when you did not get burned. Wiseman, if he wanted
to conduct a proper scientific experiment and not a circus show should have first established at what point an ordinary person
would reasonably be expected to suffer burns and then test to see if those claiming to have some paranormal ability could
exceed these parameters without being hurt.
As it is Wiseman has established nothing other than, he is not such
a Wiseman, in fact he has shown he has been rather unscientific and stupid in this experiment. It also comes as no surprise
to me that the SPR review procedure has not seen this flaw in Wiseman’s experiment and has agreed to publish it.
As is often the case, Wiseman has moved the goal posts from the claim of being able to walk on fire 12 feet at 575
degrees as Hussain did for Price in 1937 to a position where paranormal or not, one can get a negative result to satisfy his
CSICOP friends. I will leave you with this question, Why did Wiseman who always claims to be open minded
not just see if the claims of the firewalkers were above what would be expected from the average individual. We still do not
have that answer.
Chris Robinson Dream Detective and Psychic UK. August 2004. .
|